The reviews here and elsewhere show a variety of reports, both positive and negative, and it would seem there might be a problem with consistency. Honestly, the rave reviews make me wonder if some people have ever had really good Italian food!
Be that as it may, we did our reservations online for a group of 7 adults and 5 children, and were a bit apprehensive because we had three adults with a plane to catch later in the evening. The speed at which our orders were fulfilled was amazing so our fears were relieved, and our host was very gracious when bringing the food, as some of us had changed places.
Much to my chagrin I forgot to ask for the Caesar dressing "on the side", and when the salad came it was drenched in dressing. My wife couldn't eat it, but I did, even though it was disappointingly at room temperature. I like my salads cold and crisp!
The pesto chicken was ok, although the chicken was not hot all the way through.
The others in our group seemed to like their meal just fine, and we were out of there in just under an hour and on our way to the airport.
Would I recommend it? Yes, if you are really hungry for Italian food (which I was), but your expectations need to be realistic; Kauai is a long ways from Italy!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.