Seeing so many people complain about the prices, I decided to comment.
The chalkboard in the front has special happy hour prices. Pizza and beer for $10 on the night we went. Two pizzas and three beers later, our bill came up to $26.
A lot of locals there and mostly a younger crowd. Yes, its loud. Yes, some people don't know when to stop drinking. Yes, the waitresses are a little overwhelmed.
Get past that, slow down and enjoy the places you visit and focus on the important things. The food was good, the beers were correct to the style and the prices are in line with any resort town.