We went to Donny's on February 14, 2014 for Valentine's Day. There was 7 of us in our group.
The food was wonderful. We had chicken Wellington, prime rib and steak. The service was fast and friendly. I especially loved the salad bar and soups, New England clam chowder and chili.
The place was packed, but we never had to wait for anything. We definately will be going back to Donny's. The best food in Sturgeon Bay! Make sure you make reservations. It is a busy place. But that is a sign of good food.