Having just one day to stay and play in Door County, we didn't plan too far in advance as to where to go to dinner. We stopped by the Nautical Inn (on Kentucky Ave in downtown Sturgeon Bay) because they had all you can eat crab legs on Monday nights- but it was a 45 minute wait. We wandered into the trattoria on 3rd but didn't feel like we were dressed appropriately and it was super cold inside (though they have been given awesome reviews and we wanted to try it out). We saw the Inn across the street and the advertisement of it as an Inn a Pub a Bakery and Restaurant sounded good to us. They weren't as busy as every where else and were just a few dollars cheaper so we chose to eat there.
There were two dining rooms to this place- the main, and the one by the bar. We asked to sit by the bar where there was only one other couple and had to wait only a few minutes. We ordered the Gorgonzola artichoke dip for an appetizer and that was pretty good- though I thought overpowered by a rosemary flavor in the bread. I had the chicken risotto which was satisfying but not exciting. I could have easily made it at home. My boyfriend had the sausage penne and felt exactly the same way. We didn't regret our choice to eat there but didn't think much of it either. I wouldn't recommend the restaurant but I also won't give it a bad review. The only thing that seemed really off that we didn't like was that none of the staff talked to each other- or us, really. They seemed to not like the manager and definitely were not having fun.