We ate dinner at Mission Grille in September on a week long trip to Door County. The place caught our attention before we even got there as it is housed in an old church. They are known for their wine list, and I believe have won awards for such. We were not disappointed.
I had a filet cooked to perfection with wonderully interesting side dishes. My husband had a seafood/pasta dish that he said was terrific. But the most fun is that they have wine specials each evening in addition to menu specials. One of the whites on special was a variety my husband loves and is hard to find. For 8$ a glass he had a wonderful taste of one of his favorites!
The wait staff was terrific but could have been a bit more informed about their food and wine. When we asked where else to dine in Door County, our waiter brought us another staff person who he felt was more knowledgable, which we appreciated. Her suggestions were terrific (see other reviews!).
The atmosphere was quite romantic in the back, where we sat. The seats are benches made from old pews, very quaint and very private. There is a more open front porch-like area, and a side garden that would be beautiful in warmer weather.