We visited La Puerta on the recommendation of some friends. It was extremely busy on a Tuesday night and we did have to wait about 20 minutes. The hostess(es?) seemed a little disorganized and actually acknowledged the people who came in behind us first. It was very chaotic at first but we visited the Tiki Bar out back while we waited and received very prompt service there. Once we were seated, everything was fine, though it was very crowded. Our server was incredibly busy but since we are generally low maintenance, we didn't mind too much. She was very polite and apologetic for being so busy. We then moved to the bar for a few drinks and the bartenders were very friendly and attentive. It cleared out a bit after the dinner hour was over and was much more comfortable and enjoyable. We will definitely make a second visit the next time we are in Sister Bay.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.