Despite being Chicagoans, my family and I enjoy thin crust pizza too. If you're a fan of a little crunch in your pie, try Faye's. We were staying at Blue Harbor and felt like dining in one evening. Based in no small part on recommendation here on TA, were ordered two pizzas for delivery. In about 45 minutes, the pizzas arrived hot and delicious. The crust is indeed cracker-thin and the audible crunch was welcomed. I found the sauce to be not overly watery as a few commented here. I had a pepperoni & bacon pizza while my wife snarfed a mushroom and Canadian bacon pizza. The 15" large was plenty for two, although there is a monster sized 17"er available too. I'm picky about my pizzas and when I'm in Sheboygan again, Faye's will win my business.