We went to Mimma's with two other couples, seeking to share wine, food, and stories over a leisurely, casual meal. Mimma's did not disappoint! Our waiter was attentive and knowledgeable, and besides a slightly-overcooked steak ordered "medium rare", the food was delicious and appropriately sized. Three of the six of us ordered one of the specials; three ordered standard fare. I think we all agreed that the specials were the way to go because (a) it saves you from being overwhelmed by the voluminous menu; and (b) the creative, seasonal dishes were absolutely pitch-perfect.
Through appetizers, soup/salads, main dishes, deserts and port, we never felt rushed. The atmosphere was great because everything felt jovial, relaxed and comfortable!