We enjoyed the Rumpus Room last week. Though Wicked was in town, we (fortunately) scheduled out reservation for when the masses exited. Our timing (7:30) was great. A few drinks at the bar and we were seated.
Though it was a Thursday, very few people eating at 7:30 pm.
Food - WONDERFUL. Halibut and Ribeye were both OUTSTANDING.
Service - VERY attentive. Rudy was our waiter, he did a GREAT job.
Atmosphere - Very good. More subdued than Bacchus, much more casual.
One side note - though our more-than-half-full bottle of $60 wine was accidentally tossed (new bus boy), they immediately comped us a whole new bottle, opening at our table so we knew it was actually a new bottle. This, my friends, is why we choose Bartolotta restaurants. Their service is SUPERB.