I know calling Nessun Dorma an "old standard" seems silly since it hasn't been there THAT long, but it reminds me of my college days, and I'm glad it has been there for me to visit in my 7 years since.
This is one of my friends' go-to place when we want to meet up. Great value for the quality of food, and extensive beer list. I've had every sandwich there and they are all superb-it just depends on what you are looking for that night. Only minor complaint is the menu hasn't changed at all in the past almost-decade. I guess "don't mess with what works" but it'd be nice to have some variety.