The Old Feed Mill was a pleasant surprise in the quiet town of Mazomanie. The food was delicious and the portions were huge. We order the cheese pies as an appetizer which turned out to be about a pound and a half of deep fried cheese curds. Being from outside of Wisconsin, we had never had a cheese curd before and this was a great introductory to this dairy delight! Three of us ate the whole plate and spend the rest of the night feeling the weight of fried cheese curd in our bellies. Absolutely worth it. Our entrees were all delicious, including the salad my friend ordered. Seeing so many hearty/fried dishes leave the kitchen, I was skeptical that their salads would be anything but iceburg lettuce, but I was wrong! Here mixed greens and veggies were all fresh and crisp and after indulging in the curds, I wished I had had more faith and ordered the salad myself.
The reasons I am only giving the Old Feed Mill four stars has nothing to do with the food. Our server was friendly, but she did forget to bring us our soup and salads (an oversight we did not notice until much later when we were home!), and the host was really unprofessional and a bit of a scatterbrain. My wine glass and several pieces of silverware also came out a little dirty. But these were really overshadowed by how delicious the food was. We'd definitely give it another go if we found ourselves back in Mazonmanie!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.