We ate at this "Wisconsin Supper Club" recently with friends (2 couples) and had a mostly great experience. Love the supper club ambience, hearty food served and generous drinks. I had the Veal Piccatta - very good; little richer than I've ever had it before, but you can't go wrong with a little heavy cream! Others in my party had the prime rib special, and they all enjoyed it. The server was very friendly and helpful, but could have been a bit more attentive. Had to flag her down a couple of times. The only problem was with paying the bill. They have a strange policy of not splitting checks (and that's OK) but also not accepting more than one credit card per table. Really? Our bill was over $200 for the four of us, and we didn't have cash. We eat out quite often with friends and have never run into this policy before. After astonishment and some discussion, the server did volunteer to split it but it wasn't without some issue later with both our credit card companies. We really hate it that we can't go back to this lovely restaurant, but will not as long as they maintain this policy. It's a big mistake, folks!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.