I made reservations at Alexander's for my husband and I when we stayed in Door County recently. We were only staying for two nights so we wanted to go somewhere casual on the first night and then somewhere more upscale on the second night. To me, it was really overrated. Our server was attentive, but the restaurant was only about 25% full, so who knows how thorough he would have been had the place been more crowded. We ordered a shrimp tempura appetizer and got something completely different (marinated shrimp cocktail that wasn't even on the menu). We each got pasta dishes for our entrees, and mine was tasty but nothing to write home about. The atmosphere was average and the decor a bit cheap looking. We ended up paying around $100 for a meal that we could have had for half the price somewhere else. Normally I like to visit a place a couple of times so that I can order a couple different things and get a feel for the food, but considering the price I definitely would not go back.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.