We stayed here for two nights for a mini honeymoon after our wedding. The room was good - spacious, clean and comfortable. The rest of the property was nice as well - cozy without being dated.
We especially appreciated the friendly, helpful staff. We originally booked a three night stay, but realized that we wanted to bump it down to two after the free cancellation deadline had passed. I contacted the property and they didn't even hesitate in granting my request, even though it took money out of their pocket.
The location was a big plus for us as well. It's located right next to the entrance to Peninsula State Park, and walking(ish) distance from Fish Creek's shops and restaurants.
This hotel will definitely be at the top of our list when we come back to Door Co.