We met a couple in Madison and they told us to try it while we were vacationing in Door County! Fantastic pizza and a great beer selection!
1,124 - 1,128 of 1,586 reviews
We ate here at the recommendation of a friend, and we loved it! Awesome pizza, delicious cherry salad, and steller beer selection. You gotta stop here if you're in Fish Creek!
We waited for almost an hour but it was definitely worth it. My 8 year old thought it was great that they gave her pizza dough to play with while waiting for our meal. We just had pizza and salad...both were fantastic.
One of the best pizzas we've ever eaten. Definitely a must visit when you're in Door County. If you want to dine in at the restaurant get there early and even if it takes a while to get seated it is well worth the wait. They also have a building in the back that services the carry out orders which is what we used. Even then we had a wait, but we grabbed a beer and just enjoyed being in Door County for the weekend.
We love fire oven pizza, so chose to eat here for our anniversary dinner. They do not take reservations, but it was worth the wait! The inside seating is limited, and it started to rain. Luckily we got seated inside. All the staff were very accommodating. We really enjoyed the artichoke dip with fresh baked bread. If you're new to this style of pizza, I'd suggest paying the extra $1.50 to make it 1/2 & 1/2. We tried the green/gold & the veggie, absolutely delicious!