The Hammy Sammy and Yellow Submarine give an idea of the fun this shop has with its sandwiches. The bread is fresh and wonderful, and while I haven't tried many of the sandwiches, the Squeal N Gobbler is a good choice. Bonus: this shop sells Babcock Hall ice cream, made at the University of Wisconsin dairy plant and famous for its rich flavor. Extra bonus: the eclectic decor includes an electric guitar and big screen TV tuned into music videos.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.