Today is our 21st wedding anniversary. It was my choice to go to Jake's as we have always been very happy with the food. I ordered the eye of the Rib Eye steak for a change instead of the usual filet. First of all, our server was very abrupt when taking our order. I requested that my steak be done with a pink middle and asked if that was a medium or medium well. He indicated it should be a medium. The steak was delivered and that was the last time the waiter came by the table. The steak of extremely tough and over-done. I have never had a rib eye that wasn't marbalized and tender before and had my doubts that it was even a rib eye. I cut a piece off and gave it to my husband to confirm that it was over-cooked and tough. After sitting there for quite some time without attention, the server came by to see if we wanted anything else. At that time, I had the opportunity to mention the toughness of the steak. He took it to wrap it and talked to the manager about it. The manager came by and offered us free desserts in exchange for an unpleasant dining experience. This, in my mind, did not make up for paying for a $32 steak that was not enjoyable. But, we did order a sundae and a creme' brulee. Again, we waited quite a while for this to be delivered and when it finally came, the ice cream in the sundae was totally melted and not edible. All in all, our anniversary celebration was marred by the unattentiveness of our server and we will have to think twice about returning. The Milwaukee area has to many fine steak places.