Simply seeing (or hearing) the words "Pies and Pints" is enough to make my mouth water and my stomach rumble. I've never been a big fan of wings, but their dry-rubbed, crispy-skinned, spicy, tender, juicy wings have converted me (can you tell?)
My favorite food there aside, I must say the pizzas are very good as well (they tend to be thin-crusted and proportionally thin on toppings), salads are delicious, and the nachos are great. Prices are a bit high, but frankly I feel they're totally worth it.
My only caveat is that I have not and will not eat-in there. It's a tiny little hole-in-the-wall location and there's barely room to move. Take out is just fine by me.