We have been dining at Basilio's for years every time we come to Pullman for football or basketball. It has rarely disappointed us and we've run the gambit on the menu. I prefer the pasta dishes of pomodora or just recently I had a rich velvety baked pasta with an alfredo style sauce and chicken that was delicious.
You order at the counter and they bring the food to your table. You would think that would speed up the process but we seem to have to wait an inordinate amount of time for our food even when the restaurant is half full. This being my only frustration, we just make sure to allow a little extra time.
To be honest, I believe some of the sauces they use are pre-prepared and not fresh but at least they have chosen to use quality canned/frozen products. It just pays to remember you are also not at a fine dining establishment or being charged $20 a plate for your pasta.