For years now, I have heard about Pickles Deli but never made it over there until we were staying on the island for two weeks. Once we tried it, we ate there almost everyday. I would have eaten there every day three times a day if we had the money! Before we got there, we were told to order a What the F ever. Since I have a huge issue with indecisiveness, I was all over that. Keith came up with better sandwiches than I ever could have ordered myself and each time they were different. Until he made me a Reuben. Reuben sandwiches always look good to me but never taste as good as they look. But Pickles' Reuben tastes exactly the way it should; perfect! It became my regular order. So did their chai frappuccinos. They were worth every penny. I will pay extra for quality; for me that is real value. And I just could not get enough of Pickles! My husband has had their Stromboli and loved it, saying the dough tasted fresh and worth the wait for them to cook it when ordered. The owner is usually there and she is always patient and helpful, particularly with dietary needs. (My husband does not eat pork.) I fell in love with Pickles Deli, the food and the staff. I love it when I find that rare place that is doing everything right and Pickles Deli is definitely that place! I am really writing this review because I am craving it so bad right now but can't get over there. :( If you can, go to Pickles Deli!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.