I will be honest, considering this a "Gourmet Bakery and Cafe" is quite the stretch in my opinion. It is an old building which is not a problem at all but the condition of the interior is far from being considered classy and I will use the term clean with a great degree of reservation.
When we walked in we waited to be seated and were instructed by the one waitress just to sit wherever we wished. The large refrigerator with glass doors was nearly empty and the rack with the baked goods was so-so. In short, I was not knocked off my feet by the food available or the atmosphere. The cherry pie I had was just fine but at $3.99 that was expected. My date had a much larger piece of cake that was more than enough for two and cost $6.99. Add two small glasses of milk along with tip and we were right at $20.
Will we return again? Maybe, maybe not. Pickings are slim in the Smithfield area when it comes to desserts but there are much better places within driving distance for the same amount of money.