I wanted to love this place as it had gotten such rave reviews but we only liked it. We would go back though as it beats Massanutten resort eateries by a mile & back. The cheese fries were excellent...fresh boardwalk like fries smothered in cheese & sprinkled with fresh bacon bits. Nachos were fresh too but not amazing. Bacon cheeseburger was solid - coming with those nice hot fries. Yummy pancake for my little guy ( nice to be able to get breakfast at dinner esp with little ones). The apple pie a la mode was fresh as was the brownie sundae.
The only reason I can't give a better rating is the Carnegie Deli Reuben. There was/is a picture of it on the website & it looked like the real deal. Sadly when I got it there was only a slice or two of grisly corned beef:( and hardly any sauerkraut ! I've been to the Carnegie Deli so wasn't expecting it to truly match up but close would have been nice.
Kudos to our server who when made aware of my disappointment said he'd have them make another...they did and it did have twice as much meat as the first but sadly that was only about 4-5 slices...again not looking like the photo on their website. Again, I give them credit for trying to rectify things but really they should take that picture off of their website.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.