This place just opened a few months ago and they lured my bf and I in with samples of their wonderful (but a bit pricy) banana pudding during their first week, we've been regulars since.
You can either pick from one of their suggestions or create your own pizza, either way, no matter how much you choose, it's 8.50. For I believe $1 extra you can get whole wheat or gluten free options as well.
It only takes about 5mins for your pizzas to finish, and I have yet to be disappointed with taste (and we've gone a lot)
Definitely recommend their soda fountain as well, it's all cane sugar drinks and fresh lemonade.
Best day to go: Tuesdays, for their 2 for 1. Makes for a great cheap date or family outing, especially since the newly renovated theater is just next door.