After all the recommendations, I decided to give Kline's a try. I usually stay just down the street from Brusters, so that is easy and fairly decent as far as ice cream goes. But you will not regret Kilne's! Peach is one of my favorite ice cream flavors and, although I prefer the type with fresh peaches in the base,Mathis did not disappoint. The ice cream was full of flavor and had great texture. It was also not too soft- this type of ice cream quite often is already half melted by the time you get it and its a race to finish it before it turns to soup.
I also got a waffle bowl and was very good- don't know if it was homemade, but it certainly hit the spot. I also thought the portion size was perfect (another complaint of Brusters- I end up getting kids size or throwing out half of it).
Kline's also has a lot of toppings for sundaes, so if the flavor of the week doesn't pique your interest, it's still worth stopping by for an alternate flavor (they also have chocolate when I stopped by) or a sundae.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.