Excellent ice cream and fudge shop! I've been to dozens all over the East Coast and Midwest, and have found none that rival the Island Creamery. Friendly and helpful staff are there to greet you quickly and give excellent input on ice cream flavors. Menu has hundreds of options. The fudge is second only to Mackinac Island in Michigan. This place is irresistable, and definitely #1 of my places to recommend! If you go and see the line is a bit long, wait! It moves quickly, and your mouth will thank you. I don't rate many this way, but 5 stars!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.