This was just about the best ice cream (gelato) I have had outside Italy. We were only in Charlottesville one night and went there for dessert. The choice of flavours is amazing and the quality is first class. We sat inside to eat and enjoyed the atmosphere. Also, a bonus for me was the expresso coffee was served in a proper china cup and not a cardboard beaker (though you could have had one of those if you wished).
If I lived in the area I would be tempted to go there every day!