We stayed at the Inn at Ormsby Hill and had already made a reservation before checking in. When we told Yoshi (Ormsby Hill owner) we had made a reservation at the Ye Old Tavern (YOT) upon checking in, he said "excellent choice", you'll really like it there. We made a reservation for 6:30 and first had a drink at the bar which was great - bar is very small and sits only about 5-6. We were then seated at booth in the bar area which was perfect.
The service, food and ambiance were amazing. We ordered stuffed mushrooms for an appetizer which was cool and not cooked with the initial serving. We informed them of this 'issue' and the manager/owner and server could not appologize enough. The 2nd order, which was piping hot, came out of the kitchen within minutes of our voicing the complaint/concern (this is the way all restaurants should handle issue - with class and genuine concern for the patron).
We ordered the steak and salmon and the flavor of both dishes was superb. All of the sides were fresh, tasty and well balanced with the meal. We eat out about 70-80% of the time and this was one of the best meals we have had in a very long time. I would go back to the YOT in a heartbeat when back in the area.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.