Brewster's was one of the suggestions from our innkeepers (Prow'd House B and B). Great suggestion! We put the dining experience on the top of our favorites list. We ordered a 16 inch Brewster's Pizza and a small cheese pizza for our daughter. We didn't have any leftovers! The pizza was amazing. Seriously, no comparison to the delivery pizza we are accustomed to.
Brewster's micro-brew their own beer. My husband loved the Cream Ale beer. I can't say much personally about the beer, as I was the designated driver. I ordered bottle water, but the owner suggested I try his well water. I can recommend the well water! It was delicious.
They have outside seating, inside and bar seating. Our innkeepers suggested as you go in the restaurant, go right to enter the bar area. The owner is a Superbowl Champion and the bartender. He and his wife have 13 children! We saw two children helping with the family business. They were adorable and seemed to really enjoy their part of the business.
In the bar area there is limited table service - you order from the bar and pick your drinks up from the bar. The pizza is delivered to your table. Our salad came in a small to-go container and the pizza was served with paper plates, but I agree with the reviewer that said Brewster's is such a unique experience. I would call it a Wimberley experience!