I didn't know what frozen custard was so I never dropped by Andy's before my sons stopped in. The only difficulty is the menu is completely overwhelming! There are dozens of combinations all sounding really yummy! I just closed my eyes and put my finger on the menu since it would have taken ages to make an informed decision. I strongly recommend downloading a menu so you can look it over in your leisure. Second to that, take a printed menu from the counter and go back to your car for a closer inspection. In my case, my random selection worked perfectly although I won't try to describe the flavor. The only thing that didn't work out was the size. There huge! I ordered a small and I could have shared it gladly if we all hadn't had our own. Definitely worth a visit!