I took my wife here for her birthday. I didn't realize until we got there that I had actually been there before several years ago. I don't remember that experience but I'll remember this one for quite some time.
The service was excellent and the food was delicious. We had the calamari and the crab cake for appetizers. The calamari was tender and delicious but I didn't care for the fried peppers they served with it. However, the crab cake was excellent. Then for dinner, I had the beef medallions with fettuccini and my wife had the peppercorn steak with macaroni and cheese. The beef was some of the best we've ever had. It was incredibly tender, perfectly cooked and came as close to being "melt in your mouth" as beef can get. Both the fettuccini and the mac and cheese were incredibly rich and tasty.
But be warned that this is not the place to go if you're dieting. Everything is in a beurre blanc or something just as decadent. This is a place to go to celebrate reaching a weight loss goal...and then the next day you go back on your diet to take off the pounds you gained eating at Kirby's. But, if you're going to gain weight, this is the way to do it.
Our bill was about $130 before tipping for what I described above along with a Cosmopolitan. It was a little bit loud (packed on a Wednesday night) for a romantic venue but other than that it was a wonderful experience.