I would rate it a 3.5 instead of 4. The service was very slow on a Sunday afternoon. I think the server was overwhelmed with too many tables and did the best that she could. The food smelled amazing, but I made a poor salad choice - which I would NOT recommend the BJ's Cobb Salad unless you enjoy about half a head of shredded iceberg lettuce - I didn't choose well. My husband got the jambalaya and liked it a lot. My son had pizza - but think that 'hand tossed' is a bit of a stretch, maybe they tossed the pre-made pizza dough in the package in the air and then opened the package and laid it on a pan? It was okay, but not what it was advertised to be to me.
The atmosphere was very pleasant, but glad we didn't have any small children with us as the wait would have been terrible. Our drink glasses emptied long before our poor overworked server could even get by to see that, and she hustled the best that she could.
Maybe Sunday is the day to avoid?
We'll think about how much time we have, order sandwiches, burgers or pasta, and go as a small group, before we head back there again.