I'm usually never in the habit of writing reviews on places I eat but on this New Years Eve Day I must,
Having driven by Bellshire Pizza a few times and knowing that it's been in business for 40 years and given that it was really close by our home, my wife and I decided to try this place over The Mellow Mushroom and I have to say were so sadly disappointed.
The owner ( 2nd year) was friendly and the place did have a nice nastalgic vibe but thats where any good rating ended.
We ordered a Veggie Special and the Pizza itself had a terrible burnt taste and the Veg's were absoultely bland and tastless. It was so sad watching my wife trying every condiment on the table "in vain" to add flavor.
If the owners happend to read this I would hope they might bo back and re-visit the recipes and seasoning the origanal owners created and used that seemed to keep this place in business for the first 30 years.
It would have been great to have Portabella Mushrooms as opposed to the cheap unseasoned and tasteless mushrooms they use. Tomatos and fresh Spinich would have also done wonders as well.
Until that happens I have to recommed exploring any other option but this one if you're craving a good Pizza. Sorry guys...
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.