My hubby and I have been going to Venus Pie for years. We're both from Spartanburg so we spent many a date here. It's a definitely a hole-in-the-wall, no ambiance to speak of, but the food is always good. We generally split a pepperoni calzone, spinach salad, and the cheesy bread sticks. We're out the door for $20 which is practically unheard of in this day and age.
I would choose Venus Pie over any other pizza joint, hands down.