We visited Papa's Pizza over the Christmas holidays on a Thursday and have mixed feelings, though we will go back for take out. The pizza was very good at a slightly high price ($17.95 for large) but our waitress was god awful terrible. When we were seated I made the comment this is our first time here and she said "I feel sorry for you". She continued on through the meal complaining about her job (strong NY accent), was not attentive, and repeatably dropped and spilled things at our table and others. We had go get our own plates, silverware, and condiments. On top of that we were seated at the worst table in the house - in the middle of the game room under bright spot lights. Just wasn't our night.
The pizza was very good though and we'll go back for take out on our way to our weekend place in OIB. I'd rate it 4 stars for the pizza but amazingly bad service (could hardly be worse) drops it to 2. The pizza is far too good to have such bad service.