We searched all week for a place that served "all you can eat" crab legs. I read reviews, looked at photos and decided on Main Street Cafe. Our party of 5 practically starved ourselves till 3:00pm on our way out of town so we could make this a scrumptious final meal on HHI. We were more than a little dissapointed when the waitress says it is only served at dinner time starting at 5pm. Nowhere was this mentioned on the menu, Tripadvisor reviews, and website. The menu insert on the table that we ordered from also did not mention this. We were bummed and went ahead and ordered other options. Crab balls were delicious. Lobster sandwich had a mix of premium and not so premium meat which was dissapointing. Burgers and sandwiches were lackluster. Can't comment on the crab legs and only a couple people in our party said they'd consider returning next year to try them. The waitress was nice but seemed to be the only one working. A couple of the orders needed to be corrected. Make sure you tell them if you want lettuce, onion, tomato and pickle garnish for burgers. They do not bring them out unless requested. Weird! Pecan pie was delicious.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.