This was our first trip to Paulie's. What a surprise! It was the best pizza we had in a long time. We enjoyed it so much that we ate there twice during our stay in Hilton Head. On our first visit, we had a lunch-sized pizza. The crust is thin, just the way we like it. We went back for dinner with some friends and ordered pizza again. It was very good but a little under cooked. The service at dinner could have been better. We had a newer waiter, but he tried hard to please. Paulie's will be a regular stop for us.