We actually ended up at Reilley's because we didn't want to wait an hour and forty five minutes for our party of 11 to eat at, "One Hot Mama's" next door.
We walked next door and checked their wait time, (which was more like 15 minutes), and I checked their tripadvisor and urban spoon reviews and in we went.
We were dining as a large party. Oldest diner was in his 50s..youngest was 3. We had a table in the back of the restaurant which had plenty of space, and our server (Scott or Sam? We kept messing that up) was great.
Our orders covered the gamut in food variety, fish and chips, shepards pie, chicken pot pie, oyster po' boy, steak, burgers, you name it. The food in general was really good. The price, (IMO) was fabulous. Folks, this is Hilton Head, in high summer. Our check included myself, my husband, and three teens. For 5 dinners, 3 apps which we shared at the table, tea, and two beers for my husband we paid right around $100.
This wasn't just good and it wasn't just cheap. It was both. And we will be back!