ok, we went to Nantucket last night, and I have had better food at Silverbay. I had the spinach and brie salad and they gave me a tiny sliver of brie; that was the ONLY brie in the salad and brie is is in the title of the salad The dress was to thick and way to sweet for a dressing. I ordered a scallops dish that was tasty, but not fufilling at all for the cost (26), 3 scallops, small chunks of lump crab meat, 3 aparagus spears and drizzle of the sauce. My Hubby had the friend seafood platter(28), the calamari was too chewy, the crabs hushpuppies tasted like breading with dry crab flakes. their oysters where great, the fish was ok, and the shrimp were juicy and flavorful.
they did a good job setting a comfortable, and upscale atomsphere, to bad the food was lacking in the utmost way.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.