We were a large group (6), on a Friday night. I get that we aren't going to be able to be seated right away, but we put our name on the list. Wait time was estimated at one hour. There was live music and an open table on the pier, so we sat down. Turns, out we could order food outside, so we did. The poor server was the only one outside and unfortunately, the service suffered. The food was good, not great. the view is fantastic. The band was great, so we had that to listen to and distract us from our poor experience. After 2.5 hours on the list inside, our table was never called, so sure glad we ordered and ate outside.
There are better restaurants on the island, so it's unlikely we will return to Pressley's.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.