I have eaten here many times since they opened. The food- especially oysters and fried shrimp has always been good to excellent.
The problem is the service. And it's a big one. The service has never been stellar here, but it's gotten so bad that it's just not worth going anymore.
The waitstaff- especially waitresses- seem to be hired more for looks than ability. What started out as a decent seafood restaurant is turning into a bar that happens to serve some seafood. Waiting tables can be a challenge but it's also not rocket science.
After having a waitress answer a menu question by reading off the special's board (slowly, like it was a struggle), then snatching menus out of a guests's hands and disappearing was just too much. I cannot believe a waitress in an oyster bar said the special: "Umm, it tastes like seafood.." Clueless and rude.
Maybe if you sat at the oyster bar and avoided the waitstaff you could have decent meal. For me, I'm done with the place. I get snapped at enough at work to have to put up with it from waitresses in a place I'm PAYING to be in. Never again!