Our family went to New York City Pizza this summer after waiting patiently for it to open. We were very excited because the one on the island is so good and always seems to be such a good value. We all thought that the pizza was good but not spectacular. The service was also fine but not the most attentive or friendly. There's actually a lot of really good pizza in the Bluffon/Hilton Head area. I'm not sure that we'll avoid this place but we probably won't make special plans to go there either.