Had a horrible meal there after years of great visits... We visited Shelter harbor Inn once a year or more. The food was getting progressively simpler and uneventful every year. This last visit the food was really BAD. From salad to entree that tested like defrosted, frost bitten chicken to creme brulee that was thik, consistency of a hard boiled egg white and horrible. It breaks my heart to give this bad review, but someone needs to fix this.