We've been to D Carlo four times, I don't know why I never reviewed it. It is our go to place for Italian outside of Federal Hill. Don't be put off by the hamburger and fries picture, I'm not sure they even have it on their dinner menu. This is an upscale Italian menu of creative pasta dishes and meat dishes.
We've had something different each time. Our favorite appetizer so far is the meat and cheese plate, more than enough for two and probably enough for four, it is quite reasonably priced for the variety and quantity of meats and cheeses. It's harder to name a favorite entree, though last time I got the spinach pasta with mushrooms and italian sausage on the waiter's recommendation which I definitely will have again.
Service is near impeccable and quite attentive. They all know the wine list and menu quite well, so I trust their recommendations on both. The atmosphere is classy and even when crowded you are far enough apart from other tables to have privacy. This will continue to be our go to place for Italian outside of Federal Hill for many years.