Recommend this inn for its nice private upstairs suite, suitable for a friends weekend or a small family. You get a large master bedroom, sumptuous bathroom and a smaller bedroom with two twins. The hosts leave you alone if that's what you want. They are also happy to make you a pot of tea. The breakfasts were lovely.
The inn features a public tearoom that is popular for tea with scones, etc.
New Oxford is a great antiquing town and nearby many charming Pennsylvania sites, including Gettysburg.