This weekend I returned to the restaurant with a friend, excited to eat my favorite meal, the 3 Cheese Tortellini with spinach and other fresh veggies...but it's no longer on the menu. We ordered their pitas and hummus appetizer and the pitas were very burnt. It was very visible to the naked eye. My friend and I were busy catching up so I never mentioned anything to the woman server who, might I add, was very nice. My petit sirloin meal came finally came out. I ordered it cooked "medium" and it came out pretty well done. In fact, the outside of the sirloin tasted burnt. The potatoes had no flavor with fatty bacon pieces on top and the broccoli tasted like a stick of butter. Once again, I just sucked it up and ate it rather than waiting to have my meal cooked over again. My husband and I have gone to this restaurant many, many times over the years and I don't recall having issues before. I'm not sure if they have a new chef or what but I really doubt that I'll be going here again. Very disappointed. Cafe Magnolia & The Cellar used to be our favorites here on the west shore but I think I'll just stick with The Cellar.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.