I am very picky when it comes to Italian food. I either love it or hate it... there is no in between. Fenicci's falls into the love category. The restaurant is cozy and decorated with broadway posters (which I happen to adore.) The mix of posters plus Italian decor gives the restaurant a high end but still laid back atmosphere.
The food is yummy. The salad was my favorite because their house dressing is spectacular. Note: If you don't like Italian dressing you should obviously skip the house dressing. For main course I had their lasagna which comes on a very large plate. Rumor has it if you eat the entire plate of lasagna you get a certificate. I didn't try to achieve the certificate. :o)
Overall it was yummy. Well priced... I believe 5 of us ate for just at $120. And I'll definitely return.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.