My husband and I first experienced What If restaurant on E Chocolate Ave. and Main St. in Hershey a few years ago. We were refered there by the innkeeper at a local B & B/farm in which we were staying. What If is deceiving upon arrival. It is located on a Howard Johnsons establishment. You go thruough the doors and down the stairs. What If we didn't know to do that? We would have missed out on an excellent dining experience! We enjoyed our dinners enough to bring friends there on our most recent visit, September, 2012.
Both times we thoroughly enjoyed our evening. Our meals were creative in their combinations and presented with flair by a most attentive server. The chef utilizes fresh, local ingredients. There is no problem if you wish to change combinations in your entree.They offer an extensive and delicious martini menu. The desserts are made "from scrtach" and in-house, which is always a plus with us.
What If reminds me of entering a speak-easy or lounge. There are interesting prints, decor and collectibles throughout the restaurant and a color scheme of red and black. The bathroom was clean (another plus).
The combination of What If restaurant and Hershey Gardens Butterfly House made our trip well worth the 2 hour drive.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.