Theodora's is a new restaurant in Drums which was The Stagecoach for any years. The Stagecoach was very rustic, very comfortable and cozy atmosphere. The new Theodora's is more modern, clean and crisp, more elegant atmosphere. The outside bar and gazebo and landscaping very pretty. We ordered salmon, and two different pasta dishes. Mine was penne ala vodka. I've eaten this a million times which always comes with a pinkish creme sauce but not this time. The sauce was red and tasted more like a meat sauce, not bad but not what I expected. The bread that was brought to the table was delicious, more like an everything bagel taste.
We were asked if we ad a reservation, which I tried to make from early morning until just about 3:00 pm. Even though the message on their machine says to press 1 for a reservation. The restaurant opens @ 4:00 pm so I crossed my fingers that it wasn't crowded. I asked the woman if there was a problem seating us, there were about 6 people in the large dining room, she did say no but before saying that we thought we wouldn't be able to dine there. She told us you must make your reservation the night before between 4-10pm. So if you decide Saturday morning you would like to make a reservation I think you'll be out of luck. Since its opening, the parking lot is always crowded and she did say you have to make a reservation for Saturday evening.
I'll try it again with another dinner selection or maybe even for lunch.
The hostess says they are still working out the kinks so must wait and see.
We do need a restaurant in Mountain Top so I encourage everyone to try it at least once.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.