My wife and I were in Bloomsburg for genealogy research as well as an anniversary getaway. This inn is listed in the "Select Registry" Guidebook for notable places to stay, and as we've enjoyed many good experiences at Select Registry inns before, choosing Turkey Hill was a no-brainer. So confident was I that the restaurant would live up to our expectations (of other Select Registry restaurants we've dined at previously), we reserved dinners on both evenings of our stay. We weren't disappointed. From stunning salads and appetizers, through the entrées and desserts, this is one of the best restaurants we've dined at in recent years. In five years as a restaurant critic, I only gave out (5) 4 Star Ratings. Turkey Hill came close, VERY close. A pheasant entrée ("only" a 3 Star dish) fell short of the higher level attained by other courses. Desserts were fabulous and should not be avoided, at any cost! Breakfast, too, was a plus. One word describes the wait staff: impeccable.
Michael Gesner, "The Wandering Gourmet", Broadway, New Jersey