A couple of business accociates and I went to Johnathans last night (a weekday). The place was empty - I mean we were the only people in there, so I immediately was concerned we made a bad choice. However, our server was very friendly and the food was quite good.
I travel a lot and eat out regularly, so I have many nice places to compare this place to. I had the special (parmigiana encrusted halibut) and my colleagues had the razor clams. My fish was great (nice flavorful crunchy outside) and my colleagues also said their meals were very good. The only complaint was the garlic mashed potatoes had no garlic.
We will come back again when we get back on town.